If you are asked for the enthalpy
of a reaction, that means according to the equation as written. So that means you are right, ΔH
rxn = 2ΔH
f(H
2O). However, you could represent exactly the same chemical reaction by the equation H
2 + 0.5O
2 H
2O, for which ΔH = ΔH
f(H
2O). (Or indeed 436H
2 + 218O
2 436H
2O, for which...). That is why, when you talk about the enthalpy of a reaction, you must specify the equation to which ΔH applies, or the reagent for which ΔH is the enthalpy per mole.