Chemical Forums
Specialty Chemistry Forums => Citizen Chemist => Topic started by: iScience on August 03, 2014, 07:04:12 AM
-
After mixing the two, you get Sodium Acetate, which, at least in room temperature, doesn't even dissolve..
Some people say this stuff is good for house cleaning, but shouldn't a cleaning agent be a good solvent as opposed to an un-dissolving solute?
What do you guys think of this?
-
My recollection is that the concept is to have a bubbling action with excess vinegar for cleaning, plus the grittiness of baking soda and sodium acetate grinding action (a little more gentler than pumice).
-
And for a few moments there, you have an acid and a base, which are both worthwhile for cleaning things.
-
Vinegar and baking soda are both reasonable good cleaning agents because they are acidic and alkaline, respectively. A slurry of baking soda is also useful because it is abrasive and thus useful for scrubbing. I don't see any advantage in forming a vinegar-baking soda mixture though. You'll immediately form water, with the excess reagent determining the final pH. Sodium acetate might have some utility as an abrasive agent if there's any left in solution after the reaction is finished, but you could just use baking soda if it came to that.
Personally, I think people use vinegar-baking soda mixtures because they don't understand chemistry and figure if both are decent cleaning agents separately, then together they must be even better. Some of the same people probably figure mixing ammonia and bleach together will give a great cleaning agent, to much more deadly effects.
-
@Corribus
Personally, I think people use vinegar-baking soda mixtures because they don't understand chemistry and figure if both are decent cleaning agents separately, then together they must be even better.
You still might be correct, but there a lot of "green" books out there that suggest using the combination. I do not think we can paint all the authors with the same brush.