Chemical Forums
Chemistry Forums for Students => Organic Chemistry Forum => Topic started by: zerokun on May 29, 2008, 02:52:34 AM
-
A question in Murray text book --p.p524 /Q 15.30
3-chlorocyclopentene , on treatment with AgBF4 , gives a precipitate of AgCl and a stable solution of a product that shows a single 1HNMR absorption at 11.04 chemical shift.
-What is it likely structure of the product ?
-What is its relation to Huckel rule ?
I go and search for chemical shift , the 11.04 accounted for a carboxylic acid functional group
And since it is single signal, it may due to the exchange of OH disrupt coupling.
However, i cant come out with the likely structure, because in the reaction there is nothing seems can form an -OH group. I know about Huckel rule but i cant explain before i can work out the structure
Does anyone has any idea what happens when we add AgBF4 to 3-chlorocyclopropene ?
-
Hey zerokun
Is your question about 3-chlorocyclopentene or 3-chlorocyclopropene?
Rico
-
sorry, is 3-chlorocyclopropene
I try to think and come out another idea that BF4 in this case acts as base. but i not sure...and i get confused with the 1HNMR signal ??? ??? ???
-
Hey zerokun
Ok what happens is that the silver-cation takes of the chloride as a chloride-anion, an gives AgCl which precipitates. This leaves a special cation, with BF4- as the counteranion. What is the structure of this cation? An what is so special about it? (hint: this is where the Hückel rule of aromaticity comes in)
Rico
-
Hi Rico,
I think i am able to figure out
is that the 3-chlorocyclopropene becomes a special cation in this reaction? because the Cl leaves .
there is 4 pi-electron can delocalise into the ring, and the signal is due to the aromaticity of the compound (delocalization of pi electron) and not COOH as what i supposed.
Thank you for your help !
-
I think i am able to figure out
is that the 3-chlorocyclopropene becomes a special cation in this reaction? because the Cl leaves
Yes.there is 4 pi-electron can delocalise into the ring, and the signal is due to the aromaticity of the compound (delocalization of pi electron) and not COOH as what i supposed.
Correct about it not being a COOH, but count again, there are not 4 pi-electrons. What number of electrons provide you with an aromatic system according to the huckel rule (_n+_)? How many does the cyclopropene cation have?