Dear Lost and found;
A Stupid Question:
Which electrode is for you the positive electrode? Is positive for you the electrode you connected with the positive pole of your power supply? Did you remember that electrons flow opposite to the technical current?
Anyway it seems that you have forgotten, that in one “half-part” of the electrolyse cell you generated “Eau de Javel” that will destroy the oxide passivation of the very reactive aluminium definitely with time. Independent: Chlorides are poison for the oxide passivation.
On the other “half-part” of the electrolyse cell (I suggest you used on both cells aluminium strips!) you may generate your KOH, but just on the surface of the aluminium oxide the concentration will be of such high that the aluminium oxide goes into solution and the “naked” aluminium can not resist anymore and for a long time.
Which of both processes will finally be faster I can’t tell at the moment, maybe the KOH.
But definitely aluminium is one of the worst choices you could take in this situation, independent how you constructed the cells and the bridge.
Good Luck!
ARGOS++