Anything soluble added will change osmolality. If water had correct resistivity it could be contaminated with some non-electrolyte.
For such an amount of preparation it has to be some serious mistake. If my calculations are correct you you need about 7.8 kg of excess NaCl.
Have you done analysis of the samples of the wrong solution, to check concentration of cations?
Could be someone weighted wrong amounts of solids - switched masses of CaCl2 and NaCl, or NaCl and KCl, or mistakenly used the same mass twice for two different solids. Cation analysis will tell you in an instant if that's the case.