does it make sense that the majority is the B anomer even though we started with a lot more of the alpha anomer?
It could, as has been said it depends on the equilibrium constant for mutarotation.
In reality, the equilibrium composition of mannopyranose in water is ~2:1 α:β, so a 46:54 α:β mixture is not practically realistic. But it is a hypothetical question -
If the optical rotation measured 0, then it would imply that ratio based on the data you have been given. You have answered the question correctly, but the question its self does not give a real life scenario.
The actual equilibrium rotation of D-mannose is about +14; the actual rotation of α-D-mannopyranose is +29 (not +20); the actual rotation of β-D-mannopyranose is -17.
A good reference for the equilibrium composition of sugars in water:
ACIE 1969, 8, 157-166